", The Schentrup family stands for a group portrait outside their home in Parkland, Fla., on Tuesday. And then I couldn't stop crying. And when rescue came, they didn't take her with them.'". The aggravating factors include that the murders were heinous, atrocious or cruel, and that they were committed in a cold, calculated and premeditated way. Some shook their heads in anger or disbelief, others sat with their eyes closed, looking crushed. appreciated. So I'm thinking that the moaning and heavy breathing in the 1213 video is actually Maddie since a bullet to the right temple would be near instant? Feis was critically injured when he threw himself between the shooter and his students, his body taking the bullets that had been meant for them. Nikolas Cruz, 23,. "I think part of me just broke," April says, weeping as she recalls that moment. On Thursday, jurors also heard about Cruzs nonchalance after he escaped from the school. Dr. Boiko described how a fatal graze wound suffered by a third girl fractured her skull and caused brain damage. On Friday, jurors and family members of victims heard from Associate Medical Examiner Dr. Iouri Boiko, who performed autopsies on a number of MSD students the day after the massacre, which killed 17 students and staff. Robinovitz's granddaughter Alyssa was killed in the 2018 shootings. Though for the survivors and families of the 17 victims, it can seem like aeons. And if we can do some little thing that prevents people from going through that, I think we'll consider this worth the time and effort. Instead, one week earlier, she was one of 17 people gunned down at . Dr. Iouri Boiko, an associate Broward County medical examiner, said the high-velocity bullets from the AR-15-style rifle caused extensive damage, blowing off body parts and killing victims when their fragments reached internal organs. ", Her voice breaks as she continues: "I heard what they were saying, but I didn't want to hear what they were saying.". The conversation is etched in April's mind: "She said, 'I'm speaking for my sister, 'cause she can't speak. The jury must be unanimous to recommend death. 2/21/01-2/14/18. How can you not want to be there for that?. Was killed after opening the door to his classroom to let students in. With Carmen's death, I was initiated into a club no one ever wants to joinparents who have had their child taken from them by gun violence. wrote in 2019 in The South Florida Sun Sentinel. Whether it's feel, whether it's call, whether it's knock on doors, whatever it is, that they just do something. Some of the testimony has been chilling without being graphic: That two victims who were in the hallway tried to get to safety by knocking on their locked classroom door, but were killed before they could get in. But it feels necessary. Carmen Schentrup was shot inside Ronit Reoven's classroom. I think it could be either one of them tbh since we dont have a definitive answer right now. The public is hardly ever forced to confront grim evidence from autopsy reports, surveillance video and survivors testimony in proceedings held years after the deadly rampage. '", "On the other hand," April adds, "we had another family member right when this incident happened tell me, 'We have this type of gun in our home, and we no longer want it.'". Now, her parents, Philip and April, wear teal bracelets printed with her name and the dates that mark her short life: 2/21/2001-2/14/2018. BBC News A gunman who killed 17 people at his former high school has gone on trial in Florida, with jurors set to decide whether he faces the death penalty or life in prison. For a few weeks after their daughter Carmen was murdered at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School on February 14, 2018, a week shy of her 17th birthday, April and Phil Schentrup could barely. It was these intellectual arguments that were most convincing for him personally, Schentrup said. Unfortunately, Carmen never made it out of her classroom alive. Carmen was a National Merit Scholarship semifinalist, one of 53 in Broward County. After the killer pleaded guilty last year, Tony Montalto, the father of 14-year-old Gina Montalto, told CNN he deserves as much of a chance as he gave my daughter and everyone else on February 14 of 2018. The father of 17-year-old Joaquin Guac Oliver, Manuel Oliver, also believes the killer deserves death, telling CBS News, The fact that Florida has the death penalty, if its not for these kinds of cases, I dont know why do we have it.. In fact, what it will do is to continue the trauma and not allow the victims to heal and get closure, Schulman wrote. But there is more to it than that. Carmen Schentrup's parents find sleep elusive. Though the defendants guilt is not in question, prosecutors must show the jurors what happened in order to prove the aggravating factors required under Florida law to justify the death penalty, according to Gail Levine, a former Miami-Dade County prosecutor who tried 15 capital homicides. And they have seen autopsy photographs of almost all of the victims, most of whom were shot more than once. How was Aaron shot in the back of the head if he was facing the shooter and tried to grab the gun? Then Nicholas Dworet rapidly fell over in front of me. It was just failure after failure after failure. Evelyn Schentrup wears a sweatshirt designed by students involved with the March for Our Lives organization. "I think it was just hard for them being around so many reminders of her," she says. Cruz walked up and shot Meadow 5 times in the back with the bullets passing through her into Cara which killed her. "But in the end, if we allow him to have the gun that can fire indiscriminately large amounts of bullets, that's on us. hide caption, Carmen skipped a grade early on, and her parents say she never lost her strong sense of self-determination. The family has no special plans that day. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________. Their view, however, is not unanimously held. Melissa Block/NPR She doesn't want to remember her that way, but instead as the genuine and intelligent girl she was. It still boggles my mind how Carmen Schentrup was killed with a gut shot, but the other heavily wounded girl in that video (Maddy Wilford) had arguably more serious wounds. It's been one month since the mass shooting at Stoneman Douglas. And she's like, 'No, I got it. "You know, you could say 'Carmen's forever 16.' Carmen died one week shy of her 17th birthday. Anybody have links to the videos OP references? hide caption. Do you have a link to the tweet about it though by any chance ? Hers is one of 17 shrines to the victims of the Parkland shooting. I once saw Victoria, Joaquins girlfriend, tweet something how an msd memorial page posted a video on Instagram of Joaquins body while the students were being evacuated by police. Such is the nature of capital punishment: Pursuing a death sentence, even against a defendant whose guilt has never been in doubt, requires putting a community that has already survived an unthinkable tragedy through more agony. Meadow Pollack, 16, was shot nine times, at close range, including shots to the head and torso, which damaged lungs and spinal cord. She took on pre-calculus in a six-week summer session. "But schools aren't taking it seriously. Joaquin Oliver (Alcove of 3rd floor men's bathroom): Was initially shot in the knee and hand and crawled over to the bathroom to try and hide. Injured student, Meadow Pollack, crawled over to her to shield her after she had already been shot 4 times. Martin Duque (1st floor hallway, east end): Multiple gunshot wounds, was initially alive by the time police arrived but died en route to receiving medical care. All of them were failing. Carmen strikes a pose for her younger sister, Evelyn, before homecoming in the fall of 2017. Jennifer and Tony Montalto listen as the assistant medical examiner for Palm Beach county testifies about the gunshot wounds sustained by their daughter Gina Montalto, during the penalty phase of her killer's trial at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, on July 26. Ever since then, he has been working tirelessly on the issue of gun violence prevention, sitting on the Team Enough Executive Committee and helping lead a gun violence prevention chapter at his university. Very quickly, news started spreading that there had been a shooting at her daughters' high school. ", A makeshift shrine for Carmen Schentrup stands outside Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School. Another girl, shot four times, was missing much of her arm. Follow our live coverage of the decision in the Parkland shooting trial. "You can say it's the man sure," Philip says. The Schentrup family stands for a group portrait outside their home in Parkland, Fla., on Tuesday. On Valentine's Day 2018, my world forever changed. Additionally, a bullet traveling through the body at a high rate of speed can cause hydrostatic shock. "And I walk up to her and say, 'Hey, would you like daddy to help you read the book?' For Philip Schentrup, whose daughter Carmen was among the students killed at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla., each day brings the same, sharp pain. . One boy was hit with 12 gunshots, including four to the head. Before they moved west, April, who was then an elementary school principal, was given a newly created leadership job: director of school safety and security for the entire Broward County district. When they were younger, Schentrup and his sister were almost best friends, he said, thanks in part to how close they were in age. '", Carmen Schentrup at age six. 2023 Cable News Network. The book and Schentrups own research opened his eyes to issues many opponents of capital punishment point to in their critiques of the death penalty, one being its racist history in the United States and how unevenly its applied to defendants of color. They blow up like a snowstorm, he said of the bullets, which left large exit wounds. Where was Bourges when he was shot? By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. A portrait of Carmen, given to the family by a Parkland artist, hangs in the Schentrups' living room, not far from the metal urn that holds her ashes. Couresy of the Schentrup family We put a gun in his hand, or allowed him to have a gun in his hand. Carmen Schentrup was one week away from celebrating her 17th birthday when she was killed in last year's mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla. A talented musician and driven student, Carmen had dreams of becoming a medical researcher and finding a cure for the neurodegenerative disease ALS. 2. We let that happen. Was apparently conscious and able to acknowledge the officers but wasn't able to respond to their questions due to his injuries (was described as very out of it/delirious). Schentrup, who was an 18-year-old freshman at the University of Central Florida when his sister was killed, remembers her as a brainy and ambitious teenager, someone whose focus was doing well in. Alyse Young for NPR "People constantly say to me, 'I can't imagine what you're going through,'" he says. So I don't know. Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much It makes sense that most of the wounded were shot in the arms or legs. And I say 'Yup, that's Parkland, Fla." ', "But I wonder," she says, her voice catching, "do they know the people that died? She got killed in a deadly shooting by the alumni of her school inside the premises. Thats not what a Florida doctor took out, state says, Ghislaine Maxwell appeals verdict and 20-year sex-trafficking sentence, DeSantis criticism of Orlando prosecutor overlooks key facts about shooting suspect, Police report: Arrested Opa-locka cop beat wife, kids for years. "She learned how to read well before kindergarten," recalls April. In making their case for death, prosecutors have argued the shooting was calculated and premeditated, while the shooters defense attorneys have called for a life sentence, presenting evidence of his troubled upbringing at home and in school and developmental difficulties he displayed throughout his life. hide caption. Carmen was a week away from her 17th birthday when Cruz fired his semiautomatic rifle into her AP psychology class. "She would go online and find a song she loved and just practice until she did it," says her younger sister Evelyn, age 14. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. And there shouldn't be more parents like us. Carmen played guitar, violin and piano. hide caption. ", Green sticky notes mark pages of photos from Carmen's childhood that April selected to use during the funeral. "It's a hard story to tell," April adds. Carmen Schentrup, 16. Peter Wang (3rd floor hallway, west end): Was killed by a shot to the head/brain while holding a door open to the stairwell on the third floor in order to let students fleeing escape down the stairs. Mariah Carey Is Making a Secret Appearance in Broadway's Some Like It Hot Musical Watch,Mariah Carey isn't just producing the new musical Some Like It Hot, she's also got a small part in it! I believe there is a typo in Gina's blurb. She was the student whose body was visible in the the highly circulated photo/video that showed the students being evacuated from room 1213. This will not help us heal and get any kind of closure, Michael B. Schulman, whose 35-year-old son, Scott J. Beigel, was killed in the shooting, wrote in 2019 in The South Florida Sun Sentinel. Do we know who that is, out of the injuries? Gina Montalto (1st floor hallway, east end): Multiple gunshot wounds to legs/torso. GoFundMe; Facebook, Joan Cox. But particularly this one says that one survivor hid directly behind him in the corner and later used his body as a shield: Witness testimony from survivor Aalayah Eastmond describes how she hid behind Dworet during the shooting. Robert Schentrup holds flowers and a candle during a candlelight vigil at Memory Mall on the University of Central Florida campus in Orlando, Florida, on the one-year anniversary of the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, on Thursday, February 14, 2019. RT @RobSchentrup: Since Carmen's death: over 200,000 Americans have died from gun violence over 380,000 people have been shot and are living with injuries As we mark this five-year milestone, we must reflect on how far we have come and how far we have left to go. Smh who downvoted this lol? Im pretty sure he saw Cruz and then turned to run and was shot in the back of the head while he was turning. This during the penalty phase in the trial of confessed shooter Nikolas Cruz who previously plead guilty to all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder. But missing her doesn't feel like enough any more. The Schentrups have little patience for the argument that it's the shooter that's the problem, not the weapon. "I think I even tried 'I have one in college, and one here with me, and my other one is in heaven,' " she continues, through tears. Schentrup was looking forward to what their relationship would be like when they were older, believing they would have the same strong bonds he sees between his parents and their own siblings. Updated Although we won't know until or if the autopsy reports are released, Ms. Schentrup was probably hit in the liver or perhaps the diaphragm. "Just laying there still and there. Trials of gunmen who have killed so many people in mass shootings are extremely rare, because they have almost always died during the attack. 196 Martin Duque Anguiano, 14, appeared to try to shield himself, based on defensive wounds to the hands, Boiko said. "Well you should. They have reviewed disturbing photographs of children dead in classrooms. Carmen Schentrup, 16 A straight-A student and National Merit Scholarship finalist, she planned to become a doctor who researched amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, commonly called Lou Gehrig's Disease. The family does not like to disagree. But if that is true, I dont think its been publicly avalible at least. Ive spent countless hours looking for videos of the case but I dont think I ever came across that. Satz again asked about the significance of the high-powered bullets. Nah I have never even heard of that vid or seen it, if it was out there it may be impossible to find. However it may be possible that the video Victoria was referring to was the 1st floor evacuation video where you can see Luke Hoyers body. The suffering that these people endured has to be explained to the jury.. April Schentrup is a survivor fellow with the .
Watermelon Festival Hempstead, Tx 2022,
Articles C